One woman shares her experience using a butt plug for the first time. Find out what she thought about masturbating with a butt plug. Thats right boys and girls this is butt plug is available in various sizes, in either stainless steel or black silicon, featuring a pentagram with Baphomets face in it. We are awash with inferior butt plugs. dilate to a circumference they've only managed once before—this time with no assistance from a taper.