The Right and Wrong Way to Ask Your Girlfriend to try Anal . Let's say you're trying to talk your girlfriend into anal sex, and she says no. Dear Love Drive,. I've always loved having anal sex. The problem is my new girlfriend really isn't into it. She's not sure she wants to try it, and I need help trying . You can't go diving into the Hershey highway like a schoolboy's first finger in a baby-oven. The methodical enterprise to convince your girl to allow penis-anus .. If anything you should be pissed for just wanting to talk about.